TIBETAN ART, PRE-GREAT ENCAMPMENT (KARMA GAR-RI) : Indian, Newar and the ‘Three Great Tibetan Styles’ of Men-ri, Khyen-ri and Jeyu-ri (7th -15th Century) by 17th Karmapa
The Tibetan Buddhist Encyclopedia is free for everyone and has no sponsors. It is kept alive only by the little donations of its readers.
Please consider making a little donation to help me pay the server costs and expand the encyclopedia.
Enjoy your readings here and have a wonderful day!
or card![]()
PLEASE HELP
EVERY LITTLE DONATION MATTERS 🙏

TIBETAN ART, PRE-GREAT ENCAMPMENT (KARMA GAR-RI) : Indian, Newar and the ‘Three Great Tibetan Styles’ of Men-ri, Khyen-ri and Jeyu-ri (7th -15th Century) by 17th Karmapa
This article by Adele Tomlin, published on her website Dakini Translations on 12 April 2021, presents the 17th Karmapa's introduction to Tibetan art history, given on the last two days of his teachings in early 2021 and illustrated with murals from Tibetan monasteries, alongside modern scholarship. It covers the art of the 7th to 15th centuries, before the Karma Encampment style (Karma Gar-ri) and the "three great Tibetan styles" of Menri, Khyenri and Jeyuri. A following article was to cover the Encampment style itself and the contributions of the 10th Karmapa and the Tai Situpas.
The Karma Encampment
The Great Encampment (sgar chen) was the travelling camp first set up by the 4th Karmapa, Rolpe Dorje. The Karmapa explained that under the 8th Karmapa, Mikyo Dorje, it flourished, with a shedra for sutra and philosophy, a college for tantra and ritual and 300 to 400 retreatants in single tents. Two figures regarded as emanations of Mikyo Dorje, Topa Namkha Tashi and Dakpo Gopa Nangso Sidral Karma, founded the Encampment painting (sgar bris) and sculpture (sgar lugs) styles. The Karmapa suggested calling the painting style Gar-ri rather than Gardri, which could be taken to mean a style of handwriting, while leaving the question for experts. It became a distinctive Tibetan style that drew on other cultures and is still alive today.
Two periods
Following David Jackson's Patron and Painter (2009), the author divides Karma Kagyu art into two periods:[1]
- before the Encampment styles: the Eastern Indian style (shar bris, late 11th to mid-14th century), the Newar-influenced styles (bal bris, 14th to 15th century, sometimes later)[2] and the Menthangpa style (sman bris, from the mid-15th century);
- the Encampment styles: the old style (late 16th to early 18th century, the time of Namkha Tashi and Cho Tashi) and the new style (from the 1730s, beginning with Situ Panchen and the painter Karma Tashi).
She also mentions Amy Heller's division of Tibetan art history into six periods.
From the 7th to the 15th century
The Karmapa traced Tibetan art from the first temples of the kings: Rasa, Pekar, Samye and others. A mural at Rasa Trulnang, the original Jokhang, names the monks who painted it as merit for the king and all beings. He noted that many modern scholars think the Jowo statue of the Jokhang was made in Tibet rather than brought from China by Princess Wencheng. He also described:
- rock carvings of 804 and 806 CE at Drakyap and Kyekundo in Kham;
- a silk painting of the Medicine Buddha and other deities from Dunhuang, probably of 836 CE and now in the British Museum, signed by the monk Palyang, perhaps the first signed work by a Tibetan artist;[3]
- the murals of Toling and other monasteries founded by Rinchen Zangpo in 996;
- Dratang Monastery, begun in 1081 by the treasure revealer Drapa Ngonshe, revealer of the Four Medical Tantras;
- Khyura Lhachen, the twelfth-century sculptor from Ga in Kham who made the statue "Seven Wonders of Dusum Khyenpa" at Karma Gon and worked on the Jokhang, adapting the Newar style;
- the great copper statue "Ornament of the World" made at Tsurphu after 1263 by the artist Pakshi of Phayul, in the time of Karma Pakshi, probably the largest cast statue in Tibet, which survived until it was melted down in the 1970s;
- the 14th-century murals of Shalu Monastery;
- the murals of Gyantse Palkhor Chode and the Gyantse Kumbum (1427), painted by Palchen Rinchen and Sonam Paljor, whom Menla Dondrub named as his own teachers.
The three great styles
Until the 15th century most Tibetan art was in Indian or above all Newar style. The Karmapa drew on Light of the Great Sun, a commentary on iconometry written at Tsurphu in 1704 by Bhikshu Rinchen Chok of Gyaltang (born 1664), the only text that also explains the origin of the Encampment style. It describes three great styles that developed from the 15th century.
Menri. Menla Dondrub (fl. 1450s–1470s) of Menthang in Lhodrak, regarded as an emanation of Manjushri, studied with Dopa Tashi Gyalpo. On seeing a Chinese painting at Dratang he is said to have recalled a past life as an artist in China. He set the proportions of deities according to the Kalachakra and Samvarodaya tantras. The 1st Dalai Lama, Gendun Drub, who had dreamt of meeting an emanation of Manjushri, commissioned him to paint the murals at Tashilhunpo. A thangka signed by him has recently been found at Sakya. According to Jackson, the Menri style, with much more Chinese landscape, prevailed across central Tibet and was widely used by the Karma Kagyu before they developed their own style. Jackson cites an early 16th-century thangka of the 4th Shamarpa as the earliest Karma Kagyu example.
Khyenri. Khyentse Chenmo of Gongkar, a fellow student of Menla Dondrub, founded the Khyenri style. His murals survive at Gongkar Chode, many of them saved by a layer of whitewash. Himalayan Art Resources describes the style as having a bright palette, fine detail, portrait-like faces and almost perfect circles of light or flame around deities. Jackson's A Revolutionary Artist of Tibet (2016) shows that he replaced the classic red backgrounds with the greens and blues of Chinese landscape, that his work has often been mistaken for early Encampment style and that he was active from the 1450s until at least 1503. The style is now linked with the Gongkarwa branch of the Sakya.[4]
Jeyuri. The third style was that of Tulku Jeyu, nicknamed "little bird" because he flitted from place to place with his paintings and materials, studying with many masters. The Karmapa explained that here tulku is a title for makers of sacred images, not a reincarnation. Jeyu was noted for his use of colour. Jackson notes that he was one of the first painters remembered purely as a professional artist.
The 17th-century histories
The Karmapa noted that Desi Sangye Gyatso's catalogue of 1697, the main source on the Menri and Khyenri styles, does not mention the Encampment style at all, perhaps because the Karma Kagyu were being suppressed at the time. Geshe Tenzin Phuntsok (born 1673), in his works on colours and consecration (1716), likewise says that the first styles were the three great styles.
Further reading
- Kathryn Selig Brown, “Tibetan Buddhist Art”, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2000.
- Lokesh Chandra, Transcendental Art of Tibet. New Delhi, 1996.
- Karl Debreczeny, “Sino-Tibetan Artistic Synthesis in Ming Dynasty Temples at the Core and Periphery”, 2003.
- Amy Heller, Tibetan Art: Tracing the Development of Spiritual Ideals and Art in Tibet, 600–2000 A.D. (1999), Early Himalayan Art (2008), Hidden Treasures of the Himalayas (2009) and “An Early Thanka of Avalokiteśvara from the Kingdom of Guge” (2015).
- David Jackson, A History of Tibetan Painting (1996), Patron and Painter: Situ Panchen and the Revival of the Encampment Style (2009) and A Revolutionary Artist of Tibet: Khyentse Chenmo of Gongkar (2016).
- Steven M. Kossak and Jane Casey Singer, Sacred Visions: Early Paintings from Central Tibet. Metropolitan Museum of Art.
- Valrae Reynolds et al., From the Sacred Realm. Prestel, 1999.
- Ulrich von Schroeder, Indo-Tibetan Bronzes (1981), Buddhist Sculptures in Tibet (2001), Empowered Masters (2006) and 108 Buddhist Statues in Tibet (2008).
References
- ↑ Jackson (2009: 72) notes that for its first four and a half to five centuries the Karma Kagyu commissioned works in the same styles as other schools, developing its own heavily Chinese-influenced styles only from about the 1580s.
- ↑ Jackson (2009: 76) explains that these were not purely Newar but a Tibeto-Newar synthesis, with figures in rows, a mainly red palette and minimal landscape.
- ↑ The painting has a dual Tibetan and Chinese inscription, read by infrared photography and published by Heather Karmay. Roderick Whitfield notes that it shows two styles side by side.
- ↑ Jeff Watts of Himalayan Art Resources notes that Menri and Khyenri are very similar for peaceful figures but differ greatly for wrathful ones and that the "New Menri" of Choying Gyatso arose in the 17th century.
Full article
Read the full article by Adele Tomlin on Dakini Translations
This is a short summary written by the Tibetan Buddhist Encyclopedia. All rights to the original article belong to the author and to the quoted teachings and works their respective rights holders.