BRAVEHEART BUDDHA: Women and lower castes as ‘foremost’ disciples, colloquial language teachings, ‘six requisites’ of monastics and the all-male ‘first council’
The Tibetan Buddhist Encyclopedia is free for everyone and has no sponsors. It is kept alive only by the little donations of its readers.
Please consider making a little donation to help me pay the server costs and expand the encyclopedia.
Enjoy your readings here and have a wonderful day!
or card![]()
PLEASE HELP
EVERY LITTLE DONATION MATTERS 🙏

BRAVEHEART BUDDHA: Women and lower castes as ‘foremost’ disciples, colloquial language teachings, ‘six requisites’ of monastics and the all-male ‘first council’
This article by Adele Tomlin, published on her website Dakini Translations on 26 September 2021, is her edited write-up of the thirteenth day of the 17th Karmapa's 2021 teachings on the Origins of Secret Mantra. The Karmapa discussed the dating of the Buddha, his main disciples, his acceptance of all castes, his teaching in the common language, the qualities and simple life of the sangha, the spread of the teachings and the First Council. The author adds notes on the place of women in the Buddha's community, drawing on Wendy Garling's The Woman Who Raised the Buddha (2021).
The Buddha's dates
The Karmapa explained that ancient India kept few dated records and that a dating system may have begun only with Chandragupta Maurya after Alexander's invasion. Since the Buddha is accepted to have lived eighty years, scholars first try to date his passing, usually by counting back from the undisputed dates of Ashoka (ruled c. 268–232 BCE), known from his inscriptions. There are some sixty proposed dates. Among the best known are 1085 BCE (from Faxian), 949 BCE, 543 BCE (the Sri Lankan Mahavamsa, followed in Thailand), 485 BCE, 483 or 479 BCE (Samantapasadika), 477 BCE (Max Müller) and 386 BCE (Hakuju Ui). The two main modern positions place his passing either before 500 BCE or in 386 BCE. The Karmapa planned to discuss this in detail the following year. He also showed the relic vase of the Shakyas found at Piprahwa, now in the Kolkata Museum and the Lion Capital of Ashoka at Sarnath.
The Buddha's disciples
The Vimalakirti Sutra lists ten great disciples: Shariputra, Maudgalyayana, Mahakashyapa, Subhuti, Purna, Mahakatyayana, Anuruddha, Upali, Rahula and Ananda. The Karmapa noted that they came from every caste: Brahmins such as Shariputra, Maudgalyayana and the Kashyapa brothers, Kshatriyas such as Rahula, Ananda and Anuruddha, Vaishyas such as Yasa and Upali, a barber of low caste. There were also renowned nuns, such as Mahaprajapati, Yashodhara and Utpalavarna and great lay followers, from the kings Bimbisara, Ajatashatru and Prasenajit to Anathapindika, the physician Jivaka and the laywoman Vishakha.
The author notes that in the Anguttara Nikaya (AN 1.188–267) the Buddha names eighty "foremost" disciples in different qualities, including nuns, laymen and laywomen and four pairs to be emulated: the monks Sariputta and Mahamoggallana, the nuns Khema and Uppalavanna, the laymen Citta and Hatthaka and the laywomen Khujjuttara and Velukandakiya. Following Garling, she describes how the Shakya women insisted on hearing the Buddha's teachings despite the objections of the Shakya men, became lay followers and later asked for ordination. She notes that the Buddha is said to have hesitated before agreeing, after Ananda reminded him of the fourfold assembly of earlier Buddhas and that women can attain arhatship. Garling and Analayo hold that this does not show prejudice.
Courage and equality
The Karmapa explained that, compared with the Brahmanical religion, Buddhism had a broader vision and reacted against caste, empty ritual and extreme asceticism. Yet the Buddha also respected Brahmins and ascetics, judging people by their wisdom and conduct, not their caste, as he told his last disciple Subhadra and as the Assalayana and Kannakatthala suttas show. Upali, of low caste, was praised as the foremost in Vinaya. The Karmapa told the story of Sunidha, a poor latrine cleaner despised by all, who threw down his load and knelt when he met the Buddha and whom the Buddha at once welcomed as a monk. For the Karmapa, this shows the Buddha's extraordinary courage and love, greater even than his miracles.
Teaching in the common language
The Buddha taught in a colloquial language, which had never been done before. According to the Mahishasaka and Sarvastivada Vinayas, two Brahmin monks complained that the monks recited the sutras in their own dialects and proposed using Sanskrit. The Buddha replied that each should recite in his own language and that forcing people to use a foreign language would be an offence. The Karmapa explained that the Dharma must reach all beings, while learning Sanskrit could take ten to twenty years. He also saw a Mahayana spirit in the Buddha's decision to teach at all, when no one compelled him to, purely for the sake of others.
The sangha
The community first lived in Magadha, near the four great sites of Lumbini, Bodh Gaya, Sarnath and Kushinagar and after the Buddha's passing spread west and south, through disciples such as Mahakatyayana in Avanti and Purna in Sunaparanta and through merchants. The Karmapa noted that monastics, with fewer household duties, were the "mother" of the Dharma's spread and that śrāvaka means "listener". He cited a Theravada sutta comparing the sangha to the ocean in eight wondrous ways: it deepens gradually, never crosses its shore of discipline, casts out the corrupt, takes in those of all castes like rivers, has the one taste of liberation, never grows or shrinks, holds many jewels and contains great beings. Monastics led a simple wandering life with the requisites of three robes, an alms bowl, a water filter and a mat, often living under trees. Some, like Mahakashyapa, kept the twelve or thirteen ascetic practices.
The First Council
Concerned that the teachings would be lost, Mahakashyapa convened five hundred senior disciples at Rajgir to recite together what they had memorised. Although some scholars doubt it took place, the Karmapa thinks it probably did, since all eighteen schools record it. Ananda recited the sutras and Upali the Vinaya, forming two baskets of the Tripitaka. The Abhidharma was added later. The author notes that nuns and laywomen do not seem to have been present, which may partly explain the later decline in their status. The Karmapa ended by announcing a short ritual on the Buddha's deeds that he had compiled from a Kadampa source.
References
Full article
Read the full article by Adele Tomlin on Dakini Translations
This is a short summary written by the Tibetan Buddhist Encyclopedia. All rights to the original article belong to the author and to the quoted teachings and works their respective rights holders.