ORIGINS OF SECRET MANTRA (DAY 9): ‘NO SMOKE WITHOUT FIRE’, INDIAN PHILOSOPHICAL INVESTIGATIONS ON MATTER, MIND, METAPHYSICS, LOGIC AND THE MEANING OF LIFE AND REALITY (by 17th Karmapa)
The Tibetan Buddhist Encyclopedia is free for everyone and has no sponsors. It is kept alive only by the little donations of its readers.
Please consider making a little donation to help me pay the server costs and expand the encyclopedia.
Enjoy your readings here and have a wonderful day!
or card![]()
PLEASE HELP
EVERY LITTLE DONATION MATTERS 🙏
ORIGINS OF SECRET MANTRA (DAY 9): ‘NO SMOKE WITHOUT FIRE’, INDIAN PHILOSOPHICAL INVESTIGATIONS ON MATTER, MIND, METAPHYSICS, LOGIC AND THE MEANING OF LIFE AND REALITY (by 17th Karmapa)
This article by Adele Tomlin, published on her website Dakini Translations on 12 September 2021, is her edited write-up of the ninth day of the 17th Karmapa's 2021 teachings on the Origins of Secret Mantra. The Karmapa explained why philosophy arises, distinguished the orthodox and non-orthodox Indian schools and gave a historical introduction to each of the six orthodox schools (darśana): Samkhya, Yoga, Nyaya, Vaisheshika, Mimamsa and Vedanta, with their founders, texts and main views, ending with a summary. He stressed that these schools influenced Buddhist logic and were influenced by it in turn and that Buddhism could develop as it did only in such a rich intellectual environment.
The age of philosophy
The Karmapa explained that the Upanishads record ideas in fragments rather than systematic arguments, so many views arose. The first complete philosophy was Samkhya, which influenced all the later schools and the last was Vedanta, which arose to compete with it. Buddhist sources mention 62 or 96 views, but only the texts of these six schools survive. Their root texts are written in concise sutra style for easy memorisation. The 6th and 5th centuries BCE saw a worldwide flowering of thought, with Zoroaster, Confucius, Kapila and the Buddha appearing within a century or two. Philosophy begins with doubts: who am I, where do I come from and where will I go; how mind and matter are related; how the world came about and whether there is a creator; why some are born fortunate and others not; where good and evil come from; and how lasting happiness can be found.
Schools that accept the authority of the Vedas are called āstika and those that reject them nāstika. The Karmapa followed the 14th-century Summary of All Views (Sarvadarśanasaṃgraha), written from a Vedanta point of view, which ranks the schools from furthest from the Vedas to closest: Lokayata, Buddhist, Jain, Vaisheshika, Nyaya, Mimamsa, Samkhya and Yoga. He said that we should be grateful to these schools as a great achievement left to the world by Indian masters.
Samkhya
Samkhya is considered the oldest philosophical tradition in India and perhaps the world. Its name means "enumeration" and according to Richard Garbe, others mocked its followers as "counters" because they classified everything into twenty-five principles. Its founder Kapila, "the yellowish one", lived before the Buddha and was revered almost as a god, but the school never became a religion. The Samkhya Sutras attributed to him are thought by Garbe to date only from around 1380–1415. The main text is Ishvarakrishna's Samkhya Karika, which Paramartha translated into Chinese as the Seventy Golden Verses in the 6th century and which the Korean master Woncheuk cites in his great commentary on the Samdhinirmocana Sutra. Samkhya is a dualist system: everything arises from two constituents, the conscious self (puruṣa) and primal matter (prakṛti), which has three qualities. It holds that there is no creator.[1]
Yoga
Because many people could not accept Samkhya's denial of a creator, the Yoga school added a supreme god, Ishvara, to the Samkhya system and is therefore called theistic Samkhya. Yoga practice is older, but the school itself is traced to Patanjali's Yoga Sutras, whose date is uncertain, perhaps the 1st century CE. Their four chapters cover samadhi, practice (including the eight limbs, of which the last three, concentration, meditation and samadhi, together form saṃyama), powers such as clairvoyance and flight and "isolation" (kaivalya), the separation of the self from matter, which is liberation. The Karmapa explained that the school was popular for a time but declined as its followers turned to worldly mantras and cruel animal sacrifices.
Nyaya
The Nyaya, "logic", school is the root of all Indian logic. Its founder Gautama, also called Akshapada, is not to be confused with the Buddha. Nagarjuna's Finely Woven refutes its sixteen categories point by point, so it must be as early as Nagarjuna or earlier. Its root text, the Nyaya Sutras, has five books and the earliest commentary is by Vatsyayana (5th century). Later Nyaya was strongly influenced by the Buddhist logicians Dignaga, Dharmakirti and especially Dharmottara. Its best-known contribution is the five-part syllogism: there is fire on the hill, because there is smoke; wherever there is smoke there is fire, as in a kitchen; there is smoke on the hill; therefore there is fire. Removing the first two or last two steps gives Aristotle's syllogism and some scholars suggest that Aristotle may have learned from Indian logic.
Vaisheshika
Just as Yoga added to Samkhya, the Vaisheshika school added its own points to Nyaya. Its founder, the sage Kanada, was also called "grain-eater", since during his austerities he lived on grains left over by others and "owl", which the school explains as his clan name. Some scholars read kaṇa as "atom". Its root text is the Vaisheshika Sutras, with Prashastapada's Compendium of the Properties of Matter as the earliest surviving commentary. It holds that the world consists of countless eternal atoms combined by the power of karma, not by a god. The Karmapa said it is closer to physics than to philosophy and perhaps India's first physics.
Mimamsa
Mīmāṃsā means "investigation" of the Vedic texts. Originally one school, it divided into the earlier (pūrva) Mimamsa and the later (uttara) Mimamsa, Vedanta. It arose to defend the Brahmanical tradition against Samkhya and against Buddhism, which rejected caste distinctions and the value of ritual. Its founder Jaimini is said to have written the Mimamsa Sutras, the longest of the six root texts, with 2,742 verses, around 200 BCE. The earliest commentary is Shabara's. It teaches that everyone must perform the Vedic rituals and that the words of the Vedas are eternal and authorless, heard by the sages, so its followers are called "proponents of words". It is more a ritual school than a philosophy, but counts among the six because of its logical method of explanation, objection and refutation, similar to Tibetan scholastic texts.
Vedanta
Vedanta, "end of the Vedas", investigates Brahman on the basis of the Upanishads, the Bhagavad Gita and the Brahma Sutras, attributed to Badarayana or Vyasa. It is the source of most modern Hindu views, as Mimamsa is of Hindu ritual. Adi Shankara established the meaning of the Brahma Sutras and founded Advaita, non-dual, Vedanta. The Karmapa noted that his view of Brahman is very close to the Madhyamaka view of emptiness, so that some have accused him of being a hidden Buddhist. Vedanta holds that everything arises from and dissolves back into the all-pervading Brahman, rejecting both the Samkhya dualism and the Vaisheshika atoms.
Summary
The Karmapa summarised: Samkhya derives everything from two constituents; Yoga adds a creator god; Nyaya establishes logic and valid cognition; Vaisheshika says all is made of permanent atoms; Mimamsa emphasises Vedic ritual; and Vedanta says that all arises from Brahman. Samkhya and Yoga are like elder and younger siblings, Nyaya's logic aims at liberation, Vaisheshika is more physics than philosophy and Mimamsa is not really a philosophy, so in fact there are about three philosophical traditions. A Japanese scholar has argued that most of the six schools show traces of early Buddhism and so arose after it. The Karmapa also noted that grouping them as "the six orthodox schools" is a recent development in India. Traditional Tibetan and Chinese texts speak instead of the six non-Buddhist teachers.
Further reading
- Mikel Burley, Classical Sāṃkhya and Yoga. Routledge, 2007.
- George P. Conger, “Did India Influence Early Greek Philosophies?”, Philosophy East and West 2.2 (1952): 102–128.
- Jeaneane D. Fowler, Perspectives of Reality. Sussex Academic Press, 2002.
- Michel Hulin, Sāṃkhya Literature. Harrassowitz, 1978.
- Knut A. Jacobsen, Kapila, Founder of Sāṃkhya and Avatāra of Viṣṇu. Munshiram Manoharlal, 2008.
- Arthur Keith, Indian Logic and Atomism. 1921.
- Gerald James Larson, Classical Sāṃkhya. Motilal Banarsidass, 2001.
- Bimal Matilal, Nyāya-Vaiśeṣika. Harrassowitz, 1977.
- Max Müller, The Six Systems of Indian Philosophy. 1919.
- Kanchana Natarajan, “Gendering of Early Indian Philosophy: A Study of Sāṃkhyakārikā”, Economic and Political Weekly 36.17 (2001): 1398–1404.
- Stephen Phillips, Epistemology in Classical India. Routledge, 2012.
- Karl Potter, Indian Metaphysics and Epistemology. Princeton University Press, 1977.
- Frank Whaling, “Śaṅkara and Buddhism”, Journal of Indian Philosophy 7.1 (1979): 1–42.
References
- ↑ The author notes Kanchana Natarajan's study of how these two principles came to be gendered.
Full article
Read the full article by Adele Tomlin on Dakini Translations
This is a short summary written by the Tibetan Buddhist Encyclopedia. All rights to the original article belong to the author and to the quoted teachings and works their respective rights holders.