ORIGINS OF SECRET MANTRA (DAY 10): ‘DO WHATEVER YOU ENJOY’, HERETICS, HEDONISTS, NIHILISTS AND ‘NAKED ASCETICS’ IN INDIA: Sixty-two wrong views, six non-Buddhist teachers, the Charvakas and Jain followers at the time of Buddha
The Tibetan Buddhist Encyclopedia is free for everyone and has no sponsors. It is kept alive only by the little donations of its readers.
Please consider making a little donation to help me pay the server costs and expand the encyclopedia.
Enjoy your readings here and have a wonderful day!
or card![]()
PLEASE HELP
EVERY LITTLE DONATION MATTERS 🙏

ORIGINS OF SECRET MANTRA (DAY 10): ‘DO WHATEVER YOU ENJOY’, HERETICS, HEDONISTS, NIHILISTS AND ‘NAKED ASCETICS’ IN INDIA: Sixty-two wrong views, six non-Buddhist teachers, the Charvakas and Jain followers at the time of Buddha
This article by Adele Tomlin, published on her website Dakini Translations on 14 September 2021, is her edited write-up of the tenth day of the 17th Karmapa's 2021 teachings on the Origins of Secret Mantra. The Karmapa described the wandering ascetics of the Buddha's time, the sixty-two wrong views listed in the Brahmajala Sutta, the six non-Buddhist teachers, the hedonist Charvaka school, which he compared to the attitudes of many people today and Jainism, which he described as a bridge between Buddhism and Hinduism.
Brahmins and sramanas
The Karmapa explained that in the Buddha's time there were two kinds of religious people: the Brahmins, who kept the Vedic traditions and the sramanas, "those who strive", rendered in Tibetan as dge sbyong, "training in virtue". The sramanas left home young, wandered from place to place, lived in forests and practised yoga and austerities to find liberation. This way of life could flourish because of new ideas and because food was plentiful: in India's heat cooked food spoils quickly, so leftovers were readily given as alms and even children of wealthy families took up this life.
The sixty-two views
Besides the six orthodox schools, Buddhist scriptures mention ninety-five views and sixty-two wrong views. The best source for the latter is the Brahmajala Sutta of the Digha Nikaya, preserved in Pali and Chinese.[1] They are divided into eighteen views about the beginning and forty-four about the end:
- four eternalist views, held by meditators who saw with clairvoyance that beings pass from life to life over many aeons and concluded that the self is permanent;
- four partly eternalist views, held by those who remembered being in the retinue of Brahma and concluded that Brahma is permanent and his creations impermanent;
- four views on whether the world is finite or infinite, from seeing only part of the universe's destruction or formation;
- four evasive views, of those who avoided direct answers;
- two denials of cause, holding that body and mind arise by chance;
- sixteen views that the self will have perception after death, with eight that it will not and eight that it will neither have nor lack it;
- seven annihilationist views, that beings of the various realms cease at death;
- five views that liberation can be reached in this life, through sensual enjoyment or through one of the four dhyanas.
He noted that the evasive, causeless, nihilist and this-life liberation views are close to those of the six teachers.
The six teachers
The six teachers mentioned in Buddhist praises of the Buddha lived around Rajagriha and debated before King Ajatashatru. The oldest source on them is the Samaññaphala Sutta, The Fruits of the Spiritual Life, in which the king reports their answers to his question about the fruits of practice. It survives in Pali and Chinese versions that largely agree. The Karmapa noted that researchers rely on it because the Mulasarvastivada Vinaya is later. Their views were:
- Purana Kashyapa: killing, stealing and lying bring no suffering and virtue brings no reward, since there is no karma, rebirth or arhat;
- Makkhali Gosala: a sceptic who doubted virtue, vice, past and future lives and everything else, all being illusion;
- Ajita Keshakambala: at death the four elements dissolve and the continuum ends;
- Pakudha Kaccayana: stains arise without cause and so cannot be removed, so practice is pointless;
- Sanjaya Belatthiputta: evasive answers, known as "eel-wriggling";
- Nirgrantha Jnatiputra: the self is wisdom by nature and knows everything.
Apart from the last, whose teaching became the Jain religion, their views did not spread widely, but the Karmapa saw the Charvakas as preserving the sceptical and nihilist views.
The Charvakas
The Charvaka or Lokayata (Tibetan rgyang phan pa, "far flung") school, whose origin is unclear, was a materialist movement. Buddhist texts trace it to a sage called "Eye of the World" and non-Buddhist texts to Brihaspati, teacher of the gods, who is said to have taught wrong views to the asuras. No root texts survive, only fragments, for example in Kamalashila's commentaries. Both Buddhists and non-Buddhists regarded it as the worst of views and Madhava's Sarvadarshanasamgraha places it furthest from the truth of sixteen schools. Some scholars think "Charvaka" was a general name for materialist traditions.
It accepted only direct perception as a means of knowledge and held that everything, including mind, arises from the four elements by chance, with no creator. According to the Karmapa, its song denies gods, liberation, other worlds, rebirth, karma and the value of rituals, mocks sacrifices and offerings to ancestors and says one should enjoy life, even borrowing money for good food and clothes, since after cremation there is no return. The Karmapa compared its offering argument to people on a top floor in lockdown expecting to be fed by offerings made on the ground floor. He remarked that this "worst of views" is how many people think today, wanting cars and houses and doubting future lives and that it is hard to say whether this is progress or decline. A story in the Mahabharata of a possessed Brahmin executed for spreading such views suggests that they may be very old.
Jainism
The Karmapa preferred to call the Jains by their own name (rgyal ba pa) rather than "naked ascetics". Scholars differ on whether Jainism arose at the same time as Buddhism or from within it and on whether its founder was Nirgrantha Jnatiputra, as many modern scholars hold, or Vardhamana Mahavira, as the Jains say. Mahavira's life resembles the Buddha's: he went forth at twenty-nine and after twelve years of austerities became a jina, "victor" over the afflictions and taught for thirty years. According to Buddhist sources, his followers quarrelled after his death. During a famine in Magadha under Chandragupta, Bhadrabahu led some monks to Karnataka while others stayed under Sthulabhadra and when they reunited the dispute over clothing split them into the white-clad Svetambara and the "sky-clad" Digambara.
The two sects also differ on women: the Svetambara say that Mahavira had a wife and daughter and that women can attain liberation, while the Digambara do not.[2] Their shared canon was compiled by about the 5th century CE and resembles Buddhist texts. Like Buddhism, Jainism rejects the Vedas and a creator god, but like Samkhya it sees the world as made of primal matter and spirit and gives great importance to asceticism. Its three jewels are right wisdom, right faith and right conduct, the last consisting of non-violence (ahiṃsā), which Mahatma Gandhi often quoted from Jain scripture, truthfulness, not stealing, chastity and non-possession.
Further reading
- Madhava Acharya, The Sarva-darśana-saṃgraha. Tr. E. B. Cowell and A. E. Gough. Trübner, 1894.
- B. M. Barua, The Ajivikas. University of Calcutta, 1920.
- A. L. Basham, History and Doctrines of the Ājīvikas. Luzac, 1951.
- Ramkrishna Bhattacharya, “Cārvāka Fragments: A New Collection” (2002), “What the Cārvākas Originally Meant” (2010) and Studies on the Cārvāka/Lokāyata (Anthem, 2011).
- Paul Dundas, The Jains. 2002.
- Kailash Chand Jain, Lord Mahāvīra and His Times. Motilal Banarsidass, 1991.
- Charles Muller and Kenneth K. Tanaka (tr.), The Brahma's Net Sutra. 2017.
- Manisha Sethi, Escaping the World: Women Renouncers among Jains. Routledge, 2012.
- Thanissaro Bhikkhu (tr.), Samaññaphala Sutta (DN 2), 1997.
- Umasvati, Tattvārtha Sūtra. Tr. Nathmal Tatia. Yale University Press, 2010.
- Maurice Walshe (tr.), The Long Discourses of the Buddha. Wisdom, 1995.
- Leonard Zwilling and Michael J. Sweet, “The Evolution of Third-Sex Constructs in Ancient India”, 2000.
References
- ↑ The Karmapa noted that the Tibetan Kangyur contains a Brahmajala sutra but without the list of sixty-two views. The author adds that the Mahayana Brahmajala Sutra, a different text, is a Vinaya sutra translated into Chinese and Tibetan.
- ↑ The author notes that, according to the Kalpa Sutra, Mahavira's community had two and a half times as many female as male ascetics, that the nun Candanbala is said to have led 36,000 nuns and that today nuns outnumber monks. Citing Manisha Sethi, she notes that Jain literature both supports and undermines women's spiritual independence.
Full article
Read the full article by Adele Tomlin on Dakini Translations
This is a short summary written by the Tibetan Buddhist Encyclopedia. All rights to the original article belong to the author and to the quoted teachings and works their respective rights holders.